Question 17 of 51advanced⚖️ EvaluateLong Answer5 marks

In the letter, Ming's mother specifically addresses the challenges people face in pursuing their dreams. Do you think this advice is still relevant in contemporary society? If yes, why? If no, why not?

Correct Answer

Yes, Ming's mother's advice about the challenges of pursuing dreams is still highly relevant in contemporary society.

Firstly, the core truth that greatness requires effort and sacrifice remains unchanged. The mother states that what "differentiates greatness from the ordinary" is the investment of effort and sacrifice, and that reaching world-class standards demands at least ten years of singular, intensive pursuit. This reality of dedication still applies today.

Secondly, the challenge of dreams remaining mere dreams due to wishful thinking persists. Many people today still trade their dreams for security, just as the mother describes. The temptation to choose comfort over struggle is a timeless human tendency.

Thirdly, circumstances beyond one's control continue to alter people's paths. While the specific examples of war and family obligations may differ, modern individuals still face unforeseen obstacles—economic hardships, family responsibilities, or health crises—that can derail aspirations.

Finally, the mother's balanced approach of encouragement with caution is universally applicable. She doesn't discourage dreaming but urges consideration of the years needed and obstacles involved. Contemporary society, with its instant-gratification culture, needs this reminder more than ever that meaningful dreams demand patience, perseverance, and willingness to navigate difficulties.

Exercise: Critical Reflection | Q: 6 | (Page 7)
For More Understanding

Explanation

The question asks students to evaluate the relevance of the mother's advice in today's context. The answer draws from multiple points in the letter: the requirement of effort and sacrifice, the ten-year dedication needed, the tendency of dreams to remain wishes, the impact of circumstances, and the balance between encouragement and caution. A strong answer connects these textual points to contemporary relevance while maintaining the yes/no stance with clear justification.

Solution Steps

  1. Step 1: Take a clear position (Yes, the advice is still relevant)

  2. Step 2: Identify key challenges mentioned in the letter (effort, sacrifice, time, circumstances, wishful thinking)

  3. Step 3: Connect each challenge to contemporary society showing why it still applies

  4. Step 4: Explain how the mother's balanced approach remains valuable today

  5. Step 5: Conclude by reinforcing the timeless nature of these challenges