Suppose you are entrusted to evolve a local government plan of a State, what powers would you endow to the village panchayats to function as units of self-government? Mention any five powers and the justification in two lines for each of them for giving those powers.
To enable village panchayats to function as effective units of self-government, I would endow them with the following five powers:
-
Power to manage local water resources: Village panchayats should have the authority to mobilise village youth for voluntary work to revive old ponds and wells. This is justified because local people can observe environmental issues like depleting water sources and take timely action through collective participation.
-
Power to be consulted on industrial projects: Panchayats must have the right to be consulted before establishing big industries that affect villages. This is essential so that grievances of affected people are redressed and village interests are protected before any major project begins.
-
Financial powers to receive and spend funds: Panchayats should receive a fixed percentage of government expenditure (like 20%) directly. This would reduce their dependence on State and central governments for financial assistance and enable them to function independently.
-
Power to prepare local development plans: Panchayats should have the authority to make and implement development plans for their area. This is justified because development plans made by local people will have greater acceptability than those made by government officers.
-
Power to undertake community development activities: Panchayats should be empowered to promote people's participation in local development activities. This is necessary because people know their area, needs, problems and priorities best, and through collective participation they can take decisions about their own lives.
Explanation
The answer draws from the textbook context which mentions Article 243G that allows State Legislatures to endow Panchayats with powers regarding matters in the Eleventh Schedule. The context provides examples like village panchayats mobilising youth to revive water sources, Gram Sabhas passing resolutions about industrial projects, and the provision that 20% of government expenditure would be done through panchayats. The justifications are based on the rationales given in the context about why local governments are important - local people know their needs better, their plans have greater acceptability, and they can complete projects with lesser cost through community involvement.
Solution Steps
Step 1: Identified the constitutional basis from Article 243G mentioned in context
Step 2: Extracted examples of panchayat powers from the given situations (water management, consultation on industries)
Step 3: Derived financial powers from the mention of 20% expenditure through panchayats
Step 4: Used the justifications provided in the context about local government rationale
Step 5: Formulated five distinct powers with two-line justifications each