Which of the following examples represent (nearly) simple harmonic motion and which represent periodic but not simple harmonic motion?
the rotation of earth about its axis.
Periodic but not simple harmonic motion
motion of an oscillating mercury column in a U-tube.
Simple harmonic motion
motion of a ball bearing inside a smooth curved bowl, when released from a point slightly above the lower most point.
Nearly simple harmonic motion
general vibrations of a polyatomic molecule about its equilibrium position.
Periodic but not simple harmonic motion
Explanation
According to the textbook, 'Every periodic motion is not simple harmonic motion. Only that periodic motion governed by the force law F = -kx is simple harmonic.' The force in SHM must be proportional to displacement and directed towards the centre of motion. For (a), Earth's rotation is uniform circular motion without any restoring force - hence periodic but not SHM. For (b), the mercury column experiences a restoring force proportional to displacement (due to pressure difference from height difference), making it SHM. For (c), the textbook states 'The motion of a simple pendulum is simple harmonic for small angular displacement' - a ball bearing in a smooth bowl behaves similarly to a pendulum for small displacements. For (d), general vibrations of a polyatomic molecule are complex multi-mode oscillations that don't strictly follow F = -kx.